Peanut Butter and Jelly Cheesecake Recipe — Sugar & Cloth (2024)

FAQs

What can I use instead of sugar in cheesecake? ›

If you cannot find Lakanto or another brand of monkfruit sweetener, you can use any powder sugar substitute in a 1:1 ratio. You can add an extract for a different flavor variation. You can fold in fresh fruit, nut butter, or chocolate sauce for a swirl throughout the cheesecake.

That means you need to ensure both the heavy cream and the cream cheese are fridge-cold. If your ingredients are too warm, you'll end up with a soupy mixture that will never set, no matter how long you leave it in the fridge.

You can mix a tablespoon or two of cornstarch into your cheesecake filling mixture before baking. Another option is to use a little bit of flour or arrowroot powder. These ingredients will also help to thicken your filling and give it a more consistent texture.

Sweeteners like fruit juice, honey, molasses and maple syrup contain natural sugar and have some nutritional benefits. Fruit has fiber, vitamins and antioxidants. Even raw honey and maple syrup can contain antioxidants and minerals like iron, zinc, calcium and potassium.

Eggs: Three whole eggs hold the cheesecake together. I also add an extra yolk, which enhances the cake's velvety texture. (Whites tend to lighten the cake, which is actually fine — if you don't feel like separating that fourth egg and don't mind some extra airiness in the texture, just add in the whole egg.)

To prevent serious cracking, cheesecakes should always be baked in a moderate (325 to 350 degrees) oven. Thick cheesecakes (greater than 1½ to 2 inches deep) bake more uniformly at the lower end of this temperature spectrum.

Flour or cornstarch is sometimes included in cheesecake recipes to preventing cracks. If you find that you always have problems with cracking and your cheesecake recipe does not call for any flour or cornstarch, it's ok to experiment and add some cornstarch (one to two tablespoons) to the batter when you add the sugar.

Personally, I find it to be 2 cups (240g) graham cracker crumbs to 1 stick of butter to 1/3 cup sugar. For a flavor boost, use Biscoff crumbs instead of graham crackers! How long does a no-bake cheesecake take to set in the fridge? Generally at least 6 hours, but most recipes recommend an overnight rest.

Perhaps your kitchen is colder because of weather or your oven has a hot spot. For whatever reason, the cheesecake has cracked despite your best efforts. Remember, your cheesecake is still delicious, so instead of calling it a failed experiment, cover the crack with a delicious topping, like a sour cream coat.

What happens if you overmix cheesecake batter? ›

Avoid Overmixing: Unlike other cakes, where beating air into the batter is key, overmixed cheesecake can rise, fall and then crack from that excess air. Keeping ingredients (cheese, eggs, liquids and flavorings) at room temperature can help.

After the cheesecake is done, switch off the oven and let it cool down in the oven for an hour or more. Doing this helps the cheesecake to cool down slowly and helps it to set properly.

Flour might seem like an unusual addition—not all cheesecake recipes incorporate it—but it's the secret to success. A little starch helps prevent the cake from cracking and also makes the filling lighter and fluffier.

Caster sugar will work as well. Pretty much any sugar can be used. I recommend not using icing sugar/powdered sugar though. A lot of no-bake cheesecakes use this, but I don't know, it's always caused issues for me so I don't recommend using icing sugar for this recipe.

Honey Or Syrup

General recommended substitution ratios are as follows: For every cup of sugar, you can replace it with a 1/2 cup to 2/3 cup of honey or 2/3 cup agave. If using maple syrup or molasses, 3/4 cup to 1 cup will do the trick.

Sugar tenderizes bakery products by promoting a soft cake structure and preventing the overdevelopment of gluten. Sugars are humectants, which are substances that retain and preserve moisture.

For basic baked goods like sugar cookies or pound cake, using maple syrup or honey instead of sugar lends the finished product a little extra flavor. You'll need a little less of these sweeteners for your recipe—just ¾ cup of maple syrup or honey replaces a full cup of granulated sugar.